Well, that happened.
February came upon us in its usual fashion. Snow, cold, cranky peeps with colds, flu bugs, and other gnarly cruds. It seemed like just another month in the wide world of publishing.
However, mid-February proved that wrong when all hell broke loose.
Plagiarizing.
OMG the Plagiarizing.
Then the book theft… I won’t call it pirating because that makes me think of Johnny Depp and Orlando Bloom and I refuse to give a thief that sort of image or kindness.
Either way, be it via plagiarism or outright theft of an entire book, stealing is stealing, and it is wrong. So very, very wrong.
Thieves do not deserve the romanticism of being called a pirate.
Now, I was raised in a rather strict religious family, not horribly so, but certain tenants were drilled into my head at an early age. You don’t cheat. You don’t lie. You don’t steal. Seems simple enough, like these things should be common sense. However, common sense seems to have left the universe.
When a person chooses to plagiarize or upload a book for free consumption without an author’s permission, it goes against all… and I mean ALL of these tenets.
Plagiarists and thieves steal the work and words of others. They cheat the systems put in place to protect the person who created the original content and they cheat the content creator out of potential revenues. They lie to the readers who think they are getting original content in a legal and honest way. This is why, to my mind, thieves do not deserve the romanticism of being called a pirate.
So what happened with this plagiarism to which I refer?
Well, a historical romance author, Courtney Milan, whom I’ve followed on Twitter shared the news that her book – or at least one of her books – had been used by an alleged plagiarist without permission.
I will pause and note two things here… 1- I will not name names of the accused as I do not believe they deserve more attention. 2- I say “alleged” because at this point there have been no charges filed nor convictions.
But the tale does not end there… it gets worse!
Anyway, Courtney backed up her accusation of alleged plagiarism with side by side screenshots of her book(s) and the alleged plagiarists “book”. The evidence as displayed by Courtney was damning at best but then the plot thickened.
The alleged plagiarist then openly stated that she had no knowledge of such theft and blamed a ghostwriter. This seemed to be quite the cop out, in my opinion, but I was on the outside looking in so who was I to say anything? Please note here, that I, personally, do not use ghostwriters – I have too many OCD and control issues. LOL But… and that is a big BUT, I have nothing against the honest, professional ones who do their due diligence and put forth the best product possible. There is, however, a line that needs to be drawn between the upstanding ghostwriters and those who slap shit together and call it a job well done when it really isn’t.
Readers started paying closer attention to the “books” of the alleged plagiarist and speaking out. The list of authors whose books seemed to have been stolen from began to grow and with that, the list of books stolen grew. A Twitter blogger, Caffeinated Fae, began keeping a list of authors and books. And the list grew.
To date, the list comprises no less than 53 books, 34 authors, 3 websites, 3 articles, and 2 recipes. But the tale does not end there… it gets worse!
Of those 34 authors, Courtney’s name features prominently, as does Tessa Dare, Maya Banks, Nora Roberts, and Diana Gabaldon, just to name a few. Yes, you read that correctly. Nora Roberts, the author whose books your mom’s and grandmom’s read in your youth. Diana Gabaldon, whose Outlander books have been made into a most popular HBO series. Yeah, those guys.
Needless to say, this battle is now being fought by bigger entities than little people like myself, people who are willing to stand up for and stand beside their indie counterparts both big and small.
Have I mentioned that I don’t believe thieves deserve to be romanticized?
My sympathy ends where the excuses begin.
Then, let’s talk about book thieves… they suck.
In the grand scheme of things, authors, musicians, artists, movie creators – people who create the things we all love – have had an ongoing battle with what the law terms “piracy” for ages. You’ve seen the notifications when you watch a movie or seen the disclaimers all over the place when you buy a movie or a piece of music or what-have-you. But there are those who take the purposeful and vile act of this sort of thievery to a whole new level.
It has come to light that there are sites here in the US (technically, it’s an international problem, but we’ll stick to the US today) that actively, openly, and willfully encourage the theft of author’s intellectual property. They invite the users of their site to add stolen content. They state in their terms of service that if a book cannot be found, then the user can request said book and return within days or sometimes even hours to get the book. The use of the DMCA is a futile exercise. The operator of the site states if a DMCA has been sent, then they’ll wait for a bit and get the book back. The flagrant disregard for the law, the authors, and other content creators is repulsive.
Thankfully, as your resident weirdo, my books don’t seem to be popular or cool enough to be stolen so I simply soldier on, watching from the sidelines, cheering for the authors – both indie and trad. However, I can’t bring myself to feel sorry for the people who use the sites that willfully steal copyrighted property.
They attempt to garner sympathy with the “I can’t afford to buy all the books I read, I have bills to pay, children to feed, *insert other lame excuse*…” But they have a smartphone or tablet of some sort or they wouldn’t be downloading illegal content. They have internet service or they wouldn’t be downloading illegal content. If they say “but I have to go to the library, or Starbucks, or *insert other place to access free wi-fi* to get my books” then I say check out a book from said library rather than stealing one. Don’t buy that triple shot uber-doodly-whatever coffee from Starbucks, buy a book rather than stealing one.
My sympathy ends where the excuses begin. If you crunch some simple numbers, it will make you violently ill what these thieves and users steal.
Hypothetically speaking…
If one single book thieving site admits to having more than 21 million downloads… holy hell. I should be so lucky. Now, let’s multiply that number by the price of one of my eBooks – which is $3.99, you get about $83.7 MILLION stolen in one year.
Is your ass twitching yet? Mine is.
Now, let’s contemplate longevity… if that same site has been up and running for ten years… TEN YEARS! That is $837.9 MILLION that the rightful owners of the content never saw. That’s nearing a billion dollars. A billion. From one site. (and there are literally hundreds of them) Let that sink in for a minute.
But the authors get paid when the person gets the original file… right? Nope.
The Amazon policy for return does not consider “pages read” or length of time a file has been in someone’s kindle when a book is returned. The modus operandi of these thieves is to “buy” an eBook, download the file, strip the DRM (the stuff that is supposed to keep it from being stolen or otherwise distributed illegally) then they return the book for a full refund.
How do I know this? Because I, like many… no, ALL other authors, have been victim of the “Amazon Return Policy”. I had one single “reader” in Brazil “buy” ALL of my books… not just one or two; not just one series but ALL of my books in one day and systematically return ALL OF MY BOOKS. In less than a week. The same thing happened with a “reader” in Japan.
Do I think these people “read” my books? I’d be a daft prick if I was that naive.
What these “readers” don’t know or most likely don’t care about is that as authors, we can see what is bought, when, and from what Amazon market. We can see where the problems are occurring but we are without recourse to stop this practice as it is “Amazon’s Return Policy” and they refuse to look at or fix the problem.
The reading community and the writing community form a symbiotic relationship.
But, on the bright side… because there is always a silver lining somewhere.
Situations like the plagiarism and the blatant book theft tend to polarize and solidify the honest readers, writers, and the creative community as a whole. The honest authors strive to work harder to give their readers quality books regardless of the time and effort, we work for quality over quantity. The honest readers spend more time doing their due diligence to avoid the scammers and thieves. The honest readers give their favorite authors a virtual hug and say, we understand and we’ll wait for your next beautiful masterpiece. The honest readers remind the honest writers why they write.
And please, don’t kid yourself… as authors, we always know when the readers are genuine in their love for books and reading. We always know. Just as the readers always know which books are being stolen from and let the authors know what is going on.
The reading community and the writing community form a symbiotic relationship and unfortunately, the parasites seem to be overwhelming the ecosystem. We need help from the “Aqua Scum 2003” *from Finding Nemo* to clean the tank but right now, Amazon, the US FCC, and other regulatory bodies are working with an antiquated “under-gravel” filter that has been clogged by the debris of honest authors slowly dying under the toxicity and has been left uncleaned for far too long.
Why did I share the explosive ending to February with you? Because even though I run in the lower echelon of the writing world, I keep my eyes and ears open… I also get asked about the news that circulates. I may be of little consequence, but I do have readers who are spectacular and some of my very favorite people and I will never hide anything of importance from them. I like to believe that they know they can come to me for honest and sincere answers when they ask. I like to believe they prefer to be informed rather than remaining in the dark to the things that may and often do affect them as much as these things affect me.
In closing, I would like to thank my readers for being so awesome. They are some of the most patient and understanding people I’ve ever had the pleasure of being associated with. I would also like to address the liars, cheaters, scammers, and thieves who may see this… those people suck. There is a special Karma for this sort of person and Karma has a pretty heavy hand when dealing justice. Also, if you’re going to do something stupid like lie, steal, cheat, or otherwise break the law… don’t.